Friday, July 27, 2012

Woman fights HOA to keep home after $589K of invalid fines | WCNC.com Charlotte

Woman fights HOA to keep home after $589K of invalid fines | WCNC.com Charlotte: North Carolina is at a tipping point for homeowners associations. The number of homeowners living in neighborhoods governed by HOAs is now greater than those who live outside those neighborhoods. The story of how Wilfong came close to losing her home illustrates why HOA battles have become personal.

It also shows lawmakers have not heard the last of the bitterly divisive issues that pit neighbor against neighbor with attorneys on all sides. Her lawsuit opens a window on HOAs: Quasi-governmental associations that carry the big stick of foreclosure and are drawing scrutiny from state lawmakers.

“They can ruin you,” said Wilfong.
-----------------
Another HOA horror story to help spur yet another round of HOA legislative reform efforts.  As Shu Bartholomew says, "And the beat goes on."

From CCHAL: CID promotion and the California foreclosure debacle


This just in from the Center for California Homeowner Association Law--for years I have been posing the question, "What are the long-term consequences to municipalities of promoting CID construction?"  This post from Marjorie Murray is suggestive of one possible answer:
-------------------------
Evan:

Realty Trac has posted its report on foreclosure filings (Notices of Default) across the country, and once again California leads the pack. 

Note that six of the ten cities/counties with the greatest number of NODs are in the Central Valley, which are now over-run with common interest developments.  Why?  Because that's where vast tracts of land exist: land formerly dedicated to almonds, cotton, alfalfa and other crops.

Not long ago, the Center for California Homeowner Association Law researched, by county, the number of CIDs built in the Central Valley in the last decade.  The growth has been phenomenal. 

After approving dozens of huge planned unit developments in the past ten years, Stockton (San Joaquin County) went on a spending spree in anticipation of the tax revenue it believed CIDs would generate" property taxes, sales taxes, state taxes based on population. This was wishful thinking.  As readers of your blog know, the City of Stockton just filed for bankruptcy.

I won't enumerate all the public policy issues generated by this growth in the Central Valley, but two of them are worth listing: the demand for water by huge new subdivisions and the substitution of CIDs for agriculture in the California economy.  No state agency has examined these key policy issues.

Here's the Huffington Post story on the California foreclosure debacle.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/07/26/california-foreclosures-c_n_1705934.html?ir=San+Francisco&ref=topbar

Marjorie Murray, President
Center for California Homeowner Association Law
www.calhomelaw.org
3758 Grand Ave., Suite 56
Oakland, California 94610
mmurray@calhomelaw.org

Thursday, July 26, 2012

Robert L. Borosage: Mitt Romney: The Gated Candidate

Robert L. Borosage: Mitt Romney: The Gated Candidate

The wealthiest Americans often choose to live in gated communities, designed to shield them from the intrusion of those Ann Romney calls "you people."
Now, Mitt Romney is applying that same notion to his campaign for the presidency. He's offering Americans a gated candidate, with whole areas of his record walled off to keep "you people" from knowing about them.
--------------------
And now Romney is self-immolating in his European tour, having made a complete ass of himself in London. But here at home, in the land of the blind, he is neck and neck with President Obama, thanks to to Fox News and AM talk radio.  He is popular with people who don't believe in evolution, think the President was born in Kenya, and are convinced that if they had been in that theater in Aurora they would have taken care of the shooter. In reality, at best they would have shot themselves in the butt. At worst they would have killed an innocent bystander.

From CCHAL: request for feedback on rural CID situation


Just received this post from Marjorie Murray, President of the Center for California Homeowner Association Law, that I am passing along to all per her request. It is an interesting situation and I think many of you may have some thoughts to contribute:
-----------------------------------------------------
Evan: We've had many conversations about how CIDs function as local governments (without the restraints we expect of local government.)  But this query (below) illustrates too well that California local governments are going a step further: they are shifting costs to homeowners that they -- city councils and county supervisors -- don't want to bear.  No doubt this was always true, but I think the practice may be accelerating, given the budget crises in every level of California government.

Please post the query (below); we would appreciate reader feedback on this homeowner dilemma.

Marjorie Murray, President
Center for California Homeowner Association Law
www.calhomelaw.org

***************************************************************************************************************************************************

Here’s a troubling question from homeowners in a rural California county.

Their association is in a national forest.  It owns its own water system: a complex network of tanks and pipes carrying water throughout the subdivision to each home.  (There is no supply of public water  to the subdivision.)  The pipes are buried beneath the subdivision’s roads.

The subdivision roads, however, are NOT owned by the association.  They are owned – but poorly maintained -- by the county.  “Poorly maintained” means the county will occasionally fill some of the potholes, but only if the association begs county public works.

The roads are public, meaning they bear traffic from campers, SUVs, and HUMMERS on their way to campgrounds in the forest.  The weight of these sport vehicles damages the roads, but most of the damage is inflicted by logging trucks carrying their heavy loads of pine and redwoods out of the forest.

The traffic damages not only the roads, but also the association’s water system beneath them.  A proposal is now before the membership to drain its entire reserve account to repair the water system damaged by the traffic and to repair the roads, which will remain open to public -- and to future damage. 

So…who should pay for this half million dollar project and future maintenance?  The county (because these are public roads)?  The trucking companies?  The association (because it’s their water system at risk)?

This scenario is a good example of the quasi-governmental nature of common interest developments: they provide services that local governments (counties and water districts in this case) used to provide. With one big difference: the services are now privately financed – by homeowners.

So let us know what your think about the homeowners’ quandary….

CCHAL NewsBrief
July 26, 2012, copyright

Wednesday, July 25, 2012

HOA boards are wild card in litigation game, author says - News - ReviewJournal.com

HOA boards are wild card in litigation game, author says - News - ReviewJournal.com
And that author is me. The article is about the construction defect game.

$140 sewer bill turns into foreclosure notice and $50,000 tab for homeowner | The Sideshow - Yahoo! News

$140 sewer bill turns into foreclosure notice and $50,000 tab for homeowner | The Sideshow - Yahoo! News: Dominick Vulpis admits he had an outstanding $140 sewage bill. But when that bill went unpaid for four years, the $140 bill turned into a home foreclosure notice and $50,000 in debt.

MSNBC reports that Middletown, N.J., turned over the utility bill to Approved Realty Group, an investment company. The practice is far from unheard of. Private companies buy up existing debts from local governments and then pursue the responsible parties, charging interest and fees. Several states have placed limits on the amount of money these private companies can charge for unpaid public utility bills.
--------------
Another example of local governments emulating HOAs.  Privatize public debt and pay the debt collection company and legal counsel a handsome fee for their services.  In this case, an astonishing multiple of 268 times the size of the underlying delinquent sewer bill. 

Tuesday, July 24, 2012

DOWNSIZE ME: Giga-Living in Nano Houses - May/June 2012 - Sierra Magazine - Sierra Club

DOWNSIZE ME: Giga-Living in Nano Houses - May/June 2012 - Sierra Magazine - Sierra Club

Dozens of Magnolia residents threatened with foreclosure - Houston weather, traffic, news | FOX 26 | MyFoxHouston

Dozens of Magnolia residents threatened with foreclosure - Houston weather, traffic, news | FOX 26 | MyFoxHouston

But this summer's threat to take away homes in the Remington Forest subdivision has a face and a name: Michael Fitzmaurice, the subdivision's developer and president of the Remington Forest Homeowners Association....Approximately two dozen Remington Forest homeowners gathered to share their concerns over the growing number of liens Fitzmaurice has threatened to file against them or their neighbors. "He's also threatening everybody," homeowner Debbie Sloan said. "I mean I can't tell you how many people I've talked to that have already gotten a notice that have already paid their dues but they're getting notices they haven't paid their dues."
"We lost everything in the fire, so he thinks we have no records, we can't trace it, so he can come back and say hey you didn't pay back in 2003, 2004, 2005 and 2006," homeowner Shannon Montealvo said. "He thinks we can't show the records to prove we did pay."


Public records show that in 1992, Fitzmaurice pleaded guilty to numerous counts of felony grand theft in Florida.  He was sentenced to three and a half years in prison.

Read more: http://www.myfoxhouston.com/story/19094372/2012/07/23/dozens-of-magnolia-residents-threatened-with-foreclosure#ixzz21Y9qz5BZ
-----------------------
Thanks to Beanie Adolph for this link.

The Ultimate Mitt Romney Flip-Flop Collection - YouTube

The Ultimate Mitt Romney Flip-Flop Collection - YouTube
I don't usually post links to general political things, but this 20 minute video collection is so revealing that I think everybody who is going to vote on November 6 should watch it and think about what it means. In a way, Romney is perfectly consistent:  he always says whatever is most advantageous to him at the moment, regardless of what he has said in the past.  Abortion, immigration, the bailouts, gun control, blind trusts, education policy, raising the minimum wage, gay and lesbian rights, climate change...it just goes on and on for 20 minutes.

Number of California homes entering foreclosure falls to 2007 levels - latimes.com

Number of California homes entering foreclosure falls to 2007 levels - latimes.com

DataQuick President John Walsh said in a statement that it was unclear whether the drop in the number of homes entering the foreclosure process was a sign that the worst was over or simply that the process itself had slowed.


“The foreclosure process has always been the sanitation department of the housing sector,” he said. “The question is whether these lower … numbers mean that there’s less distress to process, or if we’re just seeing distress get processed at a slower pace.”


The number of homes being lost to foreclosure plunged. The number of trustee deeds, which are the public documents filed when a foreclosure is completed, fell 27.8% from the prior quarter and were down 48.5% from the same period as last year. A total of 21,851 deeds were filed last quarter.
------------
So maybe it's good and maybe it isn't.  Thanks to Fred Pilot for the link.

Monday, July 23, 2012

Illegal Front Yard Garden: Canadian Couple's Kitchen Garden Targeted By Authorities

Illegal Front Yard Garden: Canadian Couple's Kitchen Garden Targeted By Authorities

"Take a look at Josée Landry and Michel Beauchamp's gorgeous front yard kitchen garden in Drummondville, Quebec. The cucumbers, tomatoes, zucchinis, beets, onions, and brussels sprouts and other vegetables grown by the couple helped Beauchamp lose 75 pounds, and Landry 25.


"The only problem? It's illegal."
-------------------------
illegal kitchen garden

Saturday, July 21, 2012

Now It's the Big Banks That Are Getting Foreclosed On - CNBC

Now It's the Big Banks That Are Getting Foreclosed On - CNBC

"These associations have been hit hard by the housing crisis, as many delinquent borrowers stopped paying their monthly HOA dues. In some cases, HOA’s, which do have the authority in many states, managed to foreclose on properties even before the banks, by using the back dues as liens. Now the homeowner associations are taking it one step further. They are going after the banks, claiming that several of the largest lenders are not paying monthly HOA/condo fees on homes they’ve repossessed and now hold as bank-owned properties (Real Estate Owned, or commonly called REO’s)."
----------------------
Apparently the reporter just learned that HOAs are foreclosing on banks that don't pay their assessments. This isn't new, but the article has some good detail.  Thanks to Shu Bartholomew for the link.

Giving the green finger: Gardener who carved bush into rude gesture ordered to remove it | Mail Online

Giving the green finger: Gardener who carved bush into rude gesture ordered to remove it | Mail Online

"A gardener who carved a giant bush into a hand displaying a rude gesture has been ordered to remove it after being accused of committing a public order offence.
Richard Jackson has displayed the offending topiary, which shows the middle-finger sign, in his garden for the last eight years.
The 53-year-old has now been told by the council to alter it after a neighbour complained, but he has refused to comply."
---------------------------------------------
Green-fingered: The carved shrub

Thursday, July 19, 2012

Baltimore and the Libor scandal: 'We can't leave any money on the table' | Business | guardian.co.uk

Baltimore and the Libor scandal: 'We can't leave any money on the table' | Business | guardian.co.uk

"Baltimore is lead plaintiff in a class action lawsuit that alleges that banks including Barclays, Bank of America, HSBC, JP Morgan and UBS conspired to fix a set of key interest rates – the London Interbank Offered Rate, or Libor – costing the city millions in the process. So far, the Libor scandal has played out mostly under the radar in the US. But now it is gaining traction in Washington, and Baltimore's suit is putting a human face on a scandal legal experts predict could end up being the most costly of the credit crisis.


Firefighters, services for the elderly, school programmes – all these and more are being cut as a direct result of the actions of colluding bankers, Rawlings-Blake claims."
-------------
Good thing we have the British press to tell us about the biggest banking scandal in the history of money. You have to hunt through the business section to find a word about it in US papers. No wonder people have stopped reading them. But at least we know all about Tom Cruise's divorce.
If you want to read more, check out Matt Taibbi on this, via Max Keiser.

Tuesday, July 17, 2012

Marc Realty Residential sues to force several Columbia Gardens condo owners to sell - Residential News - Crain's Chicago Business

Marc Realty Residential sues to force several Columbia Gardens condo owners to sell - Residential News - Crain's Chicago Business

"A venture led by Marc Realty Residential LLC is trying to compel the owners of three condos in the Columbia Gardens building to sell their units to the venture, which took over 31 units in the project at 1615-25 W. Columbia Ave. from its developer last year. The building's condo association, which is controlled by the Marc venture, has sued the holdouts, citing language in the association's governing documents and state law that allow it to force them to sell if a supermajority of owners approve the sale of the entire building. The case highlights the problem facing many distressed-property investors that try to buy failed condo projects at a discount and then rent out the unsold units. Owning a rental building with some condos mixed in can be complicated, and many investors avoid such “fractured” projects entirely. Others look for ways to buy out existing condo owners after buying a big chunk of unsold units from the project's lender or developer. Marc tried that, but the three owners wouldn't go along, according to the lawsuit, filed last week in Cook County Circuit Court. The association argues that they must sell because the owners of 81.5 percent of the building's units voted to sell all the condos last year. Under the association's rules, it has the authority to sell the entire building if two-thirds of the property's units vote to approve the transaction, according to the complaint."
--------------------------------
Another example of forced sale in a seriously distressed condo project.  This is the statute that Marc Realty is relying on:

(765 ILCS 605/15) (from Ch. 30, par. 315)
    Sec. 15. Sale of property.
    (a) Unless a greater percentage is provided for in the declaration or bylaws, and notwithstanding the provisions of Sections 13 and 14 hereof, a majority of the unit owners where the property contains 2 units, or not less than 66 2/3% where the property contains three units, and not less than 75% where the property contains 4 or more units may, by affirmative vote at a meeting of unit owners duly called for such purpose, elect to sell the property. Such action shall be binding upon all unit owners, and it shall thereupon become the duty of every unit owner to execute and deliver such instruments and to perform all acts as in manner and form may be necessary to effect such sale, provided, however, that any unit owner who did not vote in favor of such action and who has filed written objection thereto with the manager or board of managers within 20 days after the date of the meeting at which such sale was approved shall be entitled to receive from the proceeds of such sale an amount equivalent to the value of his interest, as determined by a fair appraisal, less the amount of any unpaid assessments or charges due and owing from such unit owner. 
    (b) If there is a disagreement as to the value of the interest of a unit owner who did not vote in favor of the sale of the property, that unit owner shall have a right to designate an expert in appraisal or property valuation to represent him, in which case, the prospective purchaser of the property shall designate an expert in appraisal or property valuation to represent him, and both of these experts shall mutually designate a third expert in appraisal or property valuation. The 3 experts shall constitute a panel to determine by vote of at least 2 of the members of the panel, the value of that unit owner's interest in the property.
(Source: P.A. 86-1156.)

San Francisco Courthouse Strike Exposes Strain In City's Judicial System (PHOTOS)

San Francisco Courthouse Strike Exposes Strain In City's Judicial System (PHOTOS)

A strike at San Francisco Superior Court on Monday halted much of the city court's business as workers walked off the job demanding a resumption of labor negotiations that have been stalled since February.


Chants of "Rise up, shut it down, San Francisco's a union town," echoed off the walls of the Civic Center as hundreds of striking court workers, clad in purple Service Employees International Union T-shirts, carried signs slamming court officials for a slew of furlough days and five consecutive years without cost-of-living pay increases.
----------
Even the most basic functions of government are under major financial strain in California.

Monday, July 16, 2012

Bankruptcy choices highlight fiscal pain of cities nationwide - latimes.com

Bankruptcy choices highlight fiscal pain of cities nationwide - latimes.com

"It does not look pretty. It's not going to look pretty over the next three or four years," said Michael Pagano, dean of the College of Urban Planning and Public Affairs at the University of Illinois at Chicago. "It's a long-term structural problem, and cities need to think of new ways to collect resources to fuel their services, or they are only going to be in worse trouble."


Like hundreds of other cities around the country, Stockton, San Bernardino and Vallejo share a number of fundamental problems that drove their finances into the ground. Blue-collar cities with aging infrastructure, they have relatively poor populations. And they're saddled with ballooning pension and healthcare obligations for civic employees and retirees.


Then came the recession, and with it foreclosures, crashing property values and the disappearance of retailers that were vital to sales-tax revenue. Cities that had been scraping by suddenly found their bank accounts depleted and their budgets in a death spiral.
--------------------------------------------
My colleague Mike Pagano has it right.  Cities that have already tried every trick they know, including using CIDs, are becoming insolvent. Finding new sources of revenue will not be an easy task.

Sunday, July 15, 2012

Calif. cities eye plan to seize mortgages | AccessNorthGa

Calif. cities eye plan to seize mortgages | AccessNorthGa

Another story on the contemplated cramdown by condemnation scheme in Southern California's Inland (non) Empire.

Wells Fargo to pay $175 million to settle lending bias allegations - latimes.com

Wells Fargo to pay $175 million to settle lending bias allegations - latimes.com

Wells Fargo & Co.'s settlement of allegations that it overcharged minorities for home loans and wrongly steered them into subprime mortgages requires the bank to pay $125 million in damages, including about $10 million to African Americans and Latinos in the Los Angeles area.


The settlement, announced Thursday by theU.S. Justice Department, also requires the San Francisco company, by far the nation's largest home lender, to provide $50 million in down-payment assistance to residents of areas where the alleged discrimination had a significant effect.


Those regions include the San Francisco Bay Area and the Inland Empire but not Los Angeles County, where Wells Fargo already has provided an assistance plan for buyers.


The $175-million total is the second-largest fair-lending settlement by the civil rights arm of the Justice Department. The largest, reached in December, requiresBank of America Corp.to pay $335 million to settle claims against Countrywide Financial Corp., the aggressive Calabasas lender it acquired in 2008.
------------
And on it goes.

Analysis: In the U.S. housing market, recovery or Lost Decade? - Yahoo! News

Analysis: In the U.S. housing market, recovery or Lost Decade? - Yahoo! News
And the answer is:  Lost Decade.  This is a detailed analysis of the situation. And here is one big factor:  banks are preventing people from buying homes by the simple expedient of not making loans except to near-zero-risk borrowers, and the federal government is letting them run the show:


"In nearly every city, it now costs less to own than to rent.
But many would-be homeowners cannot buy. Lenders have virtually locked them out of the market by denying them mortgages, according to statistics from the Federal Housing Administration and a recent Morgan Stanley research report.
In May, consumers able to close on a mortgage had, on average, a near-perfect credit score. They could afford a 19 percent down payment on their new home. And they were still on track to spend no more 24 percent of their income on their new house, according to the Ellie Mae Origination Insight Report.
"Most of the population can't meet current mortgage underwriting standards," says trade publication Inside Mortgage Finance founder Guy Cecala. "They're getting eliminated before they even get to the door."

--------------
Thanks to Fred Pilot for this thoroughly depressing link.