Evan McKenzie on the rise of private urban governance and the law of homeowner and condominium associations. Contact me at ecmlaw@gmail.com
Thursday, June 09, 2011
The next foreclosure fight, redux...
I received an email from William Brown of Scottsdale, AZ, asking for a reposting of the above-linked post with its many comments. I agree that it was a great video and discussion, so here it is.
Wednesday, June 08, 2011
Our Fantasy Nation? - NYTimes.com
Our Fantasy Nation? - NYTimes.com
Guess what country most resembles the Tea Party's prescriptions for the USA?
Oh, and this:
"I’ve always made fun of these countries, but now I see echoes of that pattern of privatization of public services in America. Police budgets are being cut, but the wealthy take refuge in gated communities with private security guards. Their children are spared the impact of budget cuts at public schools and state universities because they attend private institutions."
Guess what country most resembles the Tea Party's prescriptions for the USA?
Oh, and this:
"I’ve always made fun of these countries, but now I see echoes of that pattern of privatization of public services in America. Police budgets are being cut, but the wealthy take refuge in gated communities with private security guards. Their children are spared the impact of budget cuts at public schools and state universities because they attend private institutions."
The HOA at Lexington Crossing | Flickr - Photo Sharing!
The HOA at Lexington Crossing | Flickr - Photo Sharing!
Check out this situation. Click the link above and you will see a photo. Click the link below that says "Car Stuck in Garage by HOA" and you will read the story behind it. I'm sure somebody will tell me it is just one of those "isolated incidents."
Says the homeowner whose driveway was blocked by the HOA as shown in the linked photo:
Car Stuck in Garage by HOA
"Hey all -
maybe someone can help me...
Can an HOA block my egress and ingress? They have placed three large stone pillars in front of our driveway, preventing us from leaving and my wife's car is in the garage. Her car has been stuck there for over four days so she can't work. We are beyond frustrated. The HOA president basically told us best of luck - see yea - your cable will be next to go.
We are paying our association dues - but can't keep up with all the new assessments and now with the 3k in their attorney fees we owe over 5k."
Read more: http://www.city-data.com/forum/atlanta/1298523-car-stuck-garage-hoa.html#ixzz1OjiKwZPs
----------------------
Why did this happen? What management company was this HOA using? Read on. He explains. If you look at page 3, entry number 23, of the city-data.com forum linked above, you will see that he says:
"We had an assessment done on our place last year for $1000 - I paid $500. I did not pay the other half. I Was 2 weeks late. They then doc'd me $800 in attorney fees. I called the management - Associa management and worked it out to pay an extra $100 a month until I could pay it off.
They then had another $1500 assessment done to rebuild the roofs. I could not keep up and feel behind - but made my payments plus $100 and I will continue to do so and try to make it more".
Read more: http://www.city-data.com/forum/atlanta/1298523-car-stuck-garage-hoa-3.html#ixzz1OjjXnUZ7
Check out this situation. Click the link above and you will see a photo. Click the link below that says "Car Stuck in Garage by HOA" and you will read the story behind it. I'm sure somebody will tell me it is just one of those "isolated incidents."
Says the homeowner whose driveway was blocked by the HOA as shown in the linked photo:
Car Stuck in Garage by HOA
"Hey all -
maybe someone can help me...
Can an HOA block my egress and ingress? They have placed three large stone pillars in front of our driveway, preventing us from leaving and my wife's car is in the garage. Her car has been stuck there for over four days so she can't work. We are beyond frustrated. The HOA president basically told us best of luck - see yea - your cable will be next to go.
We are paying our association dues - but can't keep up with all the new assessments and now with the 3k in their attorney fees we owe over 5k."
Read more: http://www.city-data.com/forum/atlanta/1298523-car-stuck-garage-hoa.html#ixzz1OjiKwZPs
----------------------
Why did this happen? What management company was this HOA using? Read on. He explains. If you look at page 3, entry number 23, of the city-data.com forum linked above, you will see that he says:
"We had an assessment done on our place last year for $1000 - I paid $500. I did not pay the other half. I Was 2 weeks late. They then doc'd me $800 in attorney fees. I called the management - Associa management and worked it out to pay an extra $100 a month until I could pay it off.
They then had another $1500 assessment done to rebuild the roofs. I could not keep up and feel behind - but made my payments plus $100 and I will continue to do so and try to make it more".
Read more: http://www.city-data.com/forum/atlanta/1298523-car-stuck-garage-hoa-3.html#ixzz1OjjXnUZ7
Monday, June 06, 2011
Dean Baker: "Dan Balz and the Washington Post STILL Don't Understand the Housing Bubble"
This is as clear an explanation of why housing prices collapsed, and why they will continue to fall for a while, as you will ever read.
Saturday, June 04, 2011
Police shoot fake alligator
KANSAS CITY, Mo (Reuters Life!) – Police in a suburb in the state of Missouri recently encountered one tough alligator -- or so they thought.
Officers in Independence, a Kansas City suburb, responded to a call on a Saturday evening about a large alligator lurking on the embankment of a pond, police spokesman Tom Gentry said Thursday.
An officer called a state conservation agent, who advised him to shoot the alligator because there was little that conservation officials could do at that time, Gentry said.
As instructed an officer shot the alligator, not once but twice, but both times the bullets bounced off -- because the alligator was made of cement.
-------------------------------------
Offending alligator? Don't call the cops -- call the HOA!
Officers in Independence, a Kansas City suburb, responded to a call on a Saturday evening about a large alligator lurking on the embankment of a pond, police spokesman Tom Gentry said Thursday.
An officer called a state conservation agent, who advised him to shoot the alligator because there was little that conservation officials could do at that time, Gentry said.
As instructed an officer shot the alligator, not once but twice, but both times the bullets bounced off -- because the alligator was made of cement.
-------------------------------------
Offending alligator? Don't call the cops -- call the HOA!
Friday, June 03, 2011
I'm sick of these MF snakes in this MF foreclosed home!
idaho-foreclosure-snake-home: Personal Finance News from Yahoo! Finance
Where's Samuel L. Jackson when you need him?
Where's Samuel L. Jackson when you need him?
Thursday, June 02, 2011
New York Co-op aims to combat obesity
Nice idea, but it won't be enough to combat the marketing of food and drink guaranteed to turn you into a waddling behemoth.
Newly amended bill would restrict library privatization
SACRAMENTO - Local governments would have to jump through multiple hoops before they could privatize local libraries under newly recrafted legislation moving through the Assembly.
The measure would require officials to provide detailed proof that contracting out would save money. It also would prohibit the layoffs of existing employees, among other rules.
The bill could have major implications for Riverside County. In 1997, the county became the first in the country to contract with a private company to provide library services.
--------------------------------------------
Privatizing local government services -- while controversial -- is one thing. Privatizing local government itself in the form of mandated homeowner associations is quite another.
MTA Officers Detain Man For Taking Pictures « CBS Baltimore
MTA Officers Detain Man For Taking Pictures « CBS Baltimore: "The Patriot Act says that critical infrastructure, trains, train stations, all those things require certain oversight to take pictures, whether you say they are for personal use or whatever, that’s your story,” the officer said."
----------------
And that was only a small part of the moronic harassment this man was subjected to by these Keystone Cops. They threatened to arrest him for absolutely no reason, among other things.
----------------
And that was only a small part of the moronic harassment this man was subjected to by these Keystone Cops. They threatened to arrest him for absolutely no reason, among other things.
Wednesday, June 01, 2011
Bachus Comforts Wall Street While Assailing Dodd-Frank to Voters Back Home - Bloomberg
Bachus Comforts Wall Street While Assailing Dodd-Frank to Voters Back Home - Bloomberg
An absolutely astounding story of greed and stupidity. See Matt Taibbi's piece (below) for a more pointed version of events.
An absolutely astounding story of greed and stupidity. See Matt Taibbi's piece (below) for a more pointed version of events.
The Continual Screwing of Jefferson County, Alabama | Rolling Stone Politics | Taibblog | Matt Taibbi on Politics and the Economy
The Continual Screwing of Jefferson County, Alabama | Rolling Stone Politics | Taibblog | Matt Taibbi on Politics and the Economy
Read Matt Taibbi's scathing analysis of the massive political corruption surrounding the "screwing" of Jefferson County, Alabama, by elected officials, as described more moderately above.
Read Matt Taibbi's scathing analysis of the massive political corruption surrounding the "screwing" of Jefferson County, Alabama, by elected officials, as described more moderately above.
Texas HOAs under heavy fire in Austin | wfaa.com Dallas - Fort Worth
Texas HOAs under heavy fire in Austin | wfaa.com Dallas - Fort Worth
"A wave of new laws were proposed, designed to restrict HOA powers that keep homeowners under financial duress and in the quicksand of debt.
State Sen. Royce West (D-Dallas) said what's happening to Greer is commonplace in Texas.
"You pay your legal fees, and other penalties and interest before the assessment is credited toward the assessment that you were supposed to have been paying in the first place," West said. "What that does is basically what it does to people in other areas — it puts them further and further behind."
----------------
"A wave of new laws were proposed, designed to restrict HOA powers that keep homeowners under financial duress and in the quicksand of debt.
State Sen. Royce West (D-Dallas) said what's happening to Greer is commonplace in Texas.
"You pay your legal fees, and other penalties and interest before the assessment is credited toward the assessment that you were supposed to have been paying in the first place," West said. "What that does is basically what it does to people in other areas — it puts them further and further behind."
----------------
HOA threatens to sue Possum Kingdom wildfire survivor | wfaa.com Dallas - Fort Worth
HOA threatens to sue Possum Kingdom wildfire survivor | wfaa.com Dallas - Fort Worth
The recreational vehicle and camper he is living and working out of until his home can be rebuilt is violating Article 8, Section 3(e) of the Sportsman's World Property Owners Association covenant, according to a letter Brumbelow received from a Dallas law firm.
"If you do not move the vehicles immediately, the Association is expected to file suit," the letter reads, hitting him with attorneys fees and seeking injunctive relief.
-----------------
Another example of local democracy in action. Not.
Thanks to Rodney Gray for the link.
The recreational vehicle and camper he is living and working out of until his home can be rebuilt is violating Article 8, Section 3(e) of the Sportsman's World Property Owners Association covenant, according to a letter Brumbelow received from a Dallas law firm.
"If you do not move the vehicles immediately, the Association is expected to file suit," the letter reads, hitting him with attorneys fees and seeking injunctive relief.
-----------------
Another example of local democracy in action. Not.
Thanks to Rodney Gray for the link.
Tuesday, May 31, 2011
Foreclosure flood may not have crested yet - Business - Eye on the Economy - msnbc.com
Foreclosure flood may not have crested yet - Business - Eye on the Economy - msnbc.com
"If the national foreclosure crisis were a baseball game, we would be in about the top of the sixth. And we may have to go to extra innings."
----------
I'll bet he wonders why he doesn't get invited to more parties.
"If the national foreclosure crisis were a baseball game, we would be in about the top of the sixth. And we may have to go to extra innings."
----------
I'll bet he wonders why he doesn't get invited to more parties.
Calculated Risk: Real House Prices and Price-to-Rent: Back to 1999
Calculated Risk: Real House Prices and Price-to-Rent: Back to 1999
Take a look at this graph if you are not sufficiently depressed.
Take a look at this graph if you are not sufficiently depressed.
Monday, May 30, 2011
HOA threatens to sue wildfire survivor
The recreational vehicle and camper he is living and working out of until his home can be rebuilt is violating Article 8, Section 3(e) of the Sportsman's World Property Owners Association covenant, according to a letter Brumbelow received from a Dallas law firm.
"If you do not move the vehicles immediately, the Association is expected to file suit," the letter reads, hitting him with attorneys fees and seeking injunctive relief.
The Association is on record, however, saying it is "sorry that he lost his house."
----------------------------------------------
And no FEMA trailers allowed, either.
"If you do not move the vehicles immediately, the Association is expected to file suit," the letter reads, hitting him with attorneys fees and seeking injunctive relief.
The Association is on record, however, saying it is "sorry that he lost his house."
----------------------------------------------
And no FEMA trailers allowed, either.
Sunday, May 29, 2011
The Next Foreclosure Fight
The Next Foreclosure Fight
Excellent news feature from CNBC on HOA foreclosures including CAI's Tom Skiba and attorney Bill Davis, who is the fellow being sued by John Carona's corporate entities (see below). Tom says HOA foreclosure should be used as a last resort, but that the power to foreclose is necessary to make sure the association is funded and the other owners don't have to pay their share. Bill says the purpose isn't to get money for the association but as an excuse to "shake down the homeowners for the benefit of the HOA vendors," mainly the lawyers and property managers.
Thanks to George Starapoli for the link.
Excellent news feature from CNBC on HOA foreclosures including CAI's Tom Skiba and attorney Bill Davis, who is the fellow being sued by John Carona's corporate entities (see below). Tom says HOA foreclosure should be used as a last resort, but that the power to foreclose is necessary to make sure the association is funded and the other owners don't have to pay their share. Bill says the purpose isn't to get money for the association but as an excuse to "shake down the homeowners for the benefit of the HOA vendors," mainly the lawyers and property managers.
Thanks to George Starapoli for the link.
A Needless Housing Collapse
A Needless Housing Collapse
"The success of a pioneering program for moderate-income buyers proves that the subprime disaster was not the fault of homeowners...The answer, quite simply, is that borrowers who had fixed-rate loans without hidden costs were far likelier to hold on to their homes. Subprime borrowers with adjustable-rate mortgages have cumulatively faced a "serious delinquency" rate approaching 40 percent, meaning that four out of 10 borrowers ended up at least three months late on their mortgages. From there, it's usually very hard for them to avoid foreclosure. By contrast, only 8.5 percent of Self-Help borrowers -- in the same cities and with the same financial profiles -- have fallen into such deep trouble, and fewer than 5 percent have ended up losing their homes to foreclosure."
--------------
The article is by Alyssa Katz, whose book Our Lot: How Real Estate Came to Own Us is the best thing I've read on the housing crisis. Here she talks about a program that shows how it was the terms of the mortgages that doomed so many people to foreclosure.
"The success of a pioneering program for moderate-income buyers proves that the subprime disaster was not the fault of homeowners...The answer, quite simply, is that borrowers who had fixed-rate loans without hidden costs were far likelier to hold on to their homes. Subprime borrowers with adjustable-rate mortgages have cumulatively faced a "serious delinquency" rate approaching 40 percent, meaning that four out of 10 borrowers ended up at least three months late on their mortgages. From there, it's usually very hard for them to avoid foreclosure. By contrast, only 8.5 percent of Self-Help borrowers -- in the same cities and with the same financial profiles -- have fallen into such deep trouble, and fewer than 5 percent have ended up losing their homes to foreclosure."
--------------
The article is by Alyssa Katz, whose book Our Lot: How Real Estate Came to Own Us is the best thing I've read on the housing crisis. Here she talks about a program that shows how it was the terms of the mortgages that doomed so many people to foreclosure.
Saturday, May 28, 2011
DA looks into Channelview complaints | Houston & Texas News | Chron.com - Houston Chronicle
DA looks into Channelview complaints | Houston & Texas News | Chron.com - Houston Chronicle
I don't know much about John Carona's businesses or how they conduct their affairs. Everything I have to say in this post is about Texas State Senator John Carona, human being. The man is a public figure who is actively making and influencing public policy in the area I have specialized in since 1985, and I have an obvious and legitimate reason to comment on his activities.
This article from the Houston Chronicle back in 2009 details some of the things that people were saying about Carona. I was quoted in the article on the general issue, although I was (and still am) unfamiliar with the details of these Texas incidents.
The picture that is shaping up is something like this. John Carona is a state senator who had a lot to say about the content of Texas laws on HOAs and the businesses that serve them. He is also a powerhouse in the property management field, being the principal in a complicated network of management firms in multiple states, that has expanded rapidly in recent years. These management firms are also connected with other businesses that serve HOA in other ways. As the article says,
"Carona, a five-term senator who chairs the Homeland Security and Transportation Committee, is Associa's founder, president and chief executive officer. He serves on the boards of dozens of other companies that provide banking, insurance, Web sites and other services to homeowners associations, according to his latest personal financial disclosure statements filed with the Texas Ethics Commission. Carona authored legislation in 2001 that preserved and modified homeowners associations' controversial authority to foreclose on homes based on delinquent assessments. He said he sees no conflict of interest in his involvement with legislation affecting the industry that provides much of his livelihood."
So--he is a public official, and he has a lucrative career. He has become a legislative specialist in the field where he has his business interests. These are all public facts and in and of themselves don't create any impropriety. The reporter raises the potential of a conflict of interest, and asked Carona about it, and he denies it. One can see how that could potentially happen with specific pieces of legislation, but no legislative-business conflict of interest is spelled out in the article as nearly as I can tell.
But here's the problem: when somebody, such as the homeowner/BOD member in this article, Sam Campbell, raises questions about the details of practices engaged in by Carona's firms, they get threatened by Carona's attorneys. Back to the 2009 article:
"In April, Campbell began sending information to the district attorney's office, which issued subpoenas for four Sterling Green South bank accounts. Assistant District Attorney Kelli Johnson said it will take months to analyze the records. Johnson declined to say whether the subpoenas were issued to PMG or to the banks. Carona said no one at his companies had received subpoenas related to Sterling Green South. Campbell also has sent numerous e-mail and written correspondence to PMG employees and attorneys detailing accusations that the company used Sterling Green South funds improperly. On July 31, PMG fired back. Benjamin D. Wood, a Washington, D.C., attorney representing the company, threatened to sue Campbell for defamation and business disparagement if he continues his campaign."
Now, I have no sympathy for people who maliciously libel people on the internet or anyplace else. People should be able to earn a living or serve in public office without having their character impugned. But where is the evidence that there was any defamation? It appears from the story that all Mr. Campbell did here was try to get to the bottom of some complicated transactions that he thought raised some questions about how his association's money was handled and spent. As a BOD member or even an ordinary HOA member, what is wrong with that? Isn't that an appropriate activity for somebody who has a fiduciary duty to the members? Nothing in that Houston Chronicle article looks like defamation to me. Why wouldn't Carona simply have his company or companies produce the records and explain the transactions?
And what about this new suit against Bill Davis? I have now read the petition that Carona's lawyers filed in the new case that led to the subpoena for my blog records. Again--where is the evidence of defamation? There is not one single specific act of defamation spelled out in the entire complaint. It just claims that between 2008 and 2010 Davis defamed Carona's companies (and Carona's name doesn't even appear in the entire complaint!) on "various news and information web sites," including the Dallas Morning News and city-data.com. The petition says that Davis claimed these firms "engaged in illegal behavior and unethical business practices," but there are no quotations of what was supposedly said. That's right: a defamation suit that fails even to quote a single allegedly defamatory statement...and that also fails to mention that the actual human being behind all the corporate plaintiff entities is a public figure. Why does that matter? Because in the USSC case of New York Times v. Sullivan, the court said that public officials and other public figures can't recover for libel unless they can prove "actual malice," which requires that the defendant either knew the statement was false or acted with reckless disregard for whether it was true or not. The petition pleads the elements of actual malice, but again--doesn't say what facts support the claim that Davis knew his unspecified statements were false.
I don't know Texas law, but here in Illinois I am confident that wouldn't be enough to state a valid claim.
Three questions for you:
1. Does the case against Bill Davis sound like a viable defamation suit to you? Where's the beef?
2. Is Carona using his lawyers to prevent people like Mr. Campbell and Mr. Davis from raising issues of public concern? Issues that relate directly to the very things he works on in his capacity as a legislator? If so, why is he doing that?
3. And isn't that a question that should be addressed to him, as a public official of the State of Texas, by the press?
I don't know much about John Carona's businesses or how they conduct their affairs. Everything I have to say in this post is about Texas State Senator John Carona, human being. The man is a public figure who is actively making and influencing public policy in the area I have specialized in since 1985, and I have an obvious and legitimate reason to comment on his activities.
This article from the Houston Chronicle back in 2009 details some of the things that people were saying about Carona. I was quoted in the article on the general issue, although I was (and still am) unfamiliar with the details of these Texas incidents.
The picture that is shaping up is something like this. John Carona is a state senator who had a lot to say about the content of Texas laws on HOAs and the businesses that serve them. He is also a powerhouse in the property management field, being the principal in a complicated network of management firms in multiple states, that has expanded rapidly in recent years. These management firms are also connected with other businesses that serve HOA in other ways. As the article says,
"Carona, a five-term senator who chairs the Homeland Security and Transportation Committee, is Associa's founder, president and chief executive officer. He serves on the boards of dozens of other companies that provide banking, insurance, Web sites and other services to homeowners associations, according to his latest personal financial disclosure statements filed with the Texas Ethics Commission. Carona authored legislation in 2001 that preserved and modified homeowners associations' controversial authority to foreclose on homes based on delinquent assessments. He said he sees no conflict of interest in his involvement with legislation affecting the industry that provides much of his livelihood."
So--he is a public official, and he has a lucrative career. He has become a legislative specialist in the field where he has his business interests. These are all public facts and in and of themselves don't create any impropriety. The reporter raises the potential of a conflict of interest, and asked Carona about it, and he denies it. One can see how that could potentially happen with specific pieces of legislation, but no legislative-business conflict of interest is spelled out in the article as nearly as I can tell.
But here's the problem: when somebody, such as the homeowner/BOD member in this article, Sam Campbell, raises questions about the details of practices engaged in by Carona's firms, they get threatened by Carona's attorneys. Back to the 2009 article:
"In April, Campbell began sending information to the district attorney's office, which issued subpoenas for four Sterling Green South bank accounts. Assistant District Attorney Kelli Johnson said it will take months to analyze the records. Johnson declined to say whether the subpoenas were issued to PMG or to the banks. Carona said no one at his companies had received subpoenas related to Sterling Green South. Campbell also has sent numerous e-mail and written correspondence to PMG employees and attorneys detailing accusations that the company used Sterling Green South funds improperly. On July 31, PMG fired back. Benjamin D. Wood, a Washington, D.C., attorney representing the company, threatened to sue Campbell for defamation and business disparagement if he continues his campaign."
Now, I have no sympathy for people who maliciously libel people on the internet or anyplace else. People should be able to earn a living or serve in public office without having their character impugned. But where is the evidence that there was any defamation? It appears from the story that all Mr. Campbell did here was try to get to the bottom of some complicated transactions that he thought raised some questions about how his association's money was handled and spent. As a BOD member or even an ordinary HOA member, what is wrong with that? Isn't that an appropriate activity for somebody who has a fiduciary duty to the members? Nothing in that Houston Chronicle article looks like defamation to me. Why wouldn't Carona simply have his company or companies produce the records and explain the transactions?
And what about this new suit against Bill Davis? I have now read the petition that Carona's lawyers filed in the new case that led to the subpoena for my blog records. Again--where is the evidence of defamation? There is not one single specific act of defamation spelled out in the entire complaint. It just claims that between 2008 and 2010 Davis defamed Carona's companies (and Carona's name doesn't even appear in the entire complaint!) on "various news and information web sites," including the Dallas Morning News and city-data.com. The petition says that Davis claimed these firms "engaged in illegal behavior and unethical business practices," but there are no quotations of what was supposedly said. That's right: a defamation suit that fails even to quote a single allegedly defamatory statement...and that also fails to mention that the actual human being behind all the corporate plaintiff entities is a public figure. Why does that matter? Because in the USSC case of New York Times v. Sullivan, the court said that public officials and other public figures can't recover for libel unless they can prove "actual malice," which requires that the defendant either knew the statement was false or acted with reckless disregard for whether it was true or not. The petition pleads the elements of actual malice, but again--doesn't say what facts support the claim that Davis knew his unspecified statements were false.
I don't know Texas law, but here in Illinois I am confident that wouldn't be enough to state a valid claim.
Three questions for you:
1. Does the case against Bill Davis sound like a viable defamation suit to you? Where's the beef?
2. Is Carona using his lawyers to prevent people like Mr. Campbell and Mr. Davis from raising issues of public concern? Issues that relate directly to the very things he works on in his capacity as a legislator? If so, why is he doing that?
3. And isn't that a question that should be addressed to him, as a public official of the State of Texas, by the press?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)